Difference between functional divisional and matrix structures

Improve Article

Save Article

  • Read
  • Discuss
  • Improve Article

    Save Article

    The structure under which jobs of similar nature are grouped under one department is known as Functional Structure. All the departments report to one coordinating head or executive. For example, all work related to production will come under the production department. Such type of structure is suitable for organizations that have diversified activities. It aims at promoting specialization as each partner has to perform work according to their skills, specialization, and knowledge.

    The structure under which jobs related to one product are grouped under one department is known as Divisional Structure. Such a type of structure is suitable for organizations that have more than one category of products to offer. The organization is divided into separate units or divisions, and each division is managed by a divisional manager. For example, if an organization has four divisions, then each department will have a separate department for production, marketing, finance, etc.

    Difference between Functional Structure and Divisional Structure:

    Basis

    Functional Structure

    Divisional Structure

    Meaning Functional structure refers to grouping of jobs of similar nature under one department. Divisional structure refers to grouping of jobs related to one product under one department.
    Formation It is formed on the basis of function. It is formed on the basis of product.
    Specialization                      It leads to functional specialization. It leads to product specialization.
    Responsibility Fixing responsibility for a particular department is difficult. Fixing responsibility for a particular department is easy.
    Managerial Development Managers become specialized in one function only, so there is less chance for overall managerial development. Multiple functions are performed by the managers which make managerial development easy.
    Cost It is economical as there is no duplication of work. It is not economical as all the resources are required by each department.
    Coordination In the case of a multi-product company, coordination is difficult.  Coordination is easy as all the functions related to a particular product are integrated into a single department.
    Suitability It is suitable for such organizations which have a single product or small number of products. It is suitable for organizations which have varieties of products.

    Difference between functional divisional and matrix structures
    Organizational Structure refers to a system describing an organisation’s hierarchy within which all the managerial tasks are performed. It represents the authority-activity relationship in an organization. The two most commonly used structures of the organization are functional structure and divisional structure. The functional organisational structure is one where employees are grouped together, according to their area of specialisation.

    On the other hand, divisional organisation structure refers to the structure wherein the organisational functions are grouped together, into divisions, depending on product, service, market or geographies. Take a glance at this article to know the difference between functional and divisional structure.

    1. Comparison Chart
    2. Definition
    3. Key Differences
    4. Conclusion

    Comparison Chart

    Basis for ComparisonFunctional StructureDivisional Structure
    Meaning Functional Structure is one in which the reporting relationships of the organization are bifurcated according to their functional area. An organizational structure wherein the organizational functions are classified into divisions as per product or service lines , market, is called Divisional Structure.
    Basis Functional areas Specialized divisions
    Responsibility Difficult to fix responsibility on a particular department. Easy to fix responsibility for performance.
    Autonomy of decisions Managers do not have autonomy of decisions. Managers have autonomy of decisions.
    Cost Economical, as the functions are not repeated. Expensive as it involves repeatation of resources.
    Appropriate for Small and simple organizations. Large and dynamic organizations.

    Definition of Functional Structure

    The functional structure is one such structure, in which the activities of similar nature are grouped together, i.e. the activities belonging a particular function are taken together as a separate department. These independent departments have their own functions to perform and objectives to pursue. For instance, there are autonomous departments for marketing, production, purchase, human resource, research and development, etc. in an organisation.

    In a functional organisational structure, each department is supervised by a functional head called as the department manager. The manager would be an expert in the respective field, and he will be held responsible for the performance of his department. Moreover, the functional heads of all the departments report directly to the top management of the organisation.

    Definition of Divisional Structure

    Divisional Structure is defined as an organisational structure that clubs together various functions on the basis of product lines and regional divisions. Further, each division of the organisation has its own essential resources and functions like production, marketing, purchase, human resource, etc. In this type of organisational structure, the divisions are headed by the general manager who controls the regular business activities. The general manager is accountable to the top management of the organisation for the performance of their division.

    Divisional Structure is applied to those organisation which are large and have more than one product line to continue. Suppose an organisation produces and sells four products, A, B, C, D. All these products are organised into separate departments and operated as individual units which are supported by functions.

    Key Differences Between Functional and Divisional Structure

    The difference between functional and divisional structure can be drawn clearly on the following grounds:

    1. The functional structure is described as an organisational structure wherein; the employees are classified on the basis of their area of specialisation. An organisational structure so designed that it is bifurcated into semi-autonomous divisions on the basis of product, service, market, etc., is known as the divisional structure.
    2. In the functional structure, the specialisation is based on functions. On the other hand, divisional structure, the specialisation depends on product lines.
    3. In the functional structure, it is really difficult to fix responsibility, i.e. Suppose a product does not perform well in the market, then it is difficult to identify, that which department (production, sales, finance, etc.) of the organisation is not doing well. As opposed to, the divisional structure where it is easy to fix responsibility, as every product of the organisation has separate departments.
    4. Managerial development is not easy in functional structure due to the absence of autonomy of decisions, as the decisions are guided by top management. As against this, divisional structure there exists autonomy of decisions. Hence managerial development is easier.
    5. The cost involved in functional organisation structure is comparatively less as the functions are not repeated. Unlike, the divisional organisational structure wherein there is the repetition of resources, and so it is costly.
    6. The functional structure is best suited to those organisation which is small and simple. As compared to divisional structure, which is appropriate for those organisations, that are large and dynamic.

    Conclusion

    As every coin has two sides, similarly both the organisational structure has their own merits and demerits. Therefore, it is a bit difficult to say, that which one is better than the other in a particular condition, but on the basis of their suitability, it can be concluded that which one is good for a particular organisation.

    What is the difference of matrix structure from functional and divisional?

    A matrix structure is a hybrid of the functional and divisional structures. It may involve employees reporting to different bosses depending on their current assignment. For example, a software design specialist may report to her boss in IT, but she's also brought onto specific projects because of her expertise.

    What are the 3 types of organizational structures?

    The four types of organizational structures are functional, multi-divisional, flat, and matrix structures.

    What are the 4 types of organization?

    There are 4 main types of business organization: sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, and Limited Liability Company, or LLC.

    What are the 4 types of organizational structures in healthcare?

    Previous studies mentioned four organizational structures for hospitals, which are budgetary, autonomous, corporate, and private. Nevertheless, healthcare decision-makers are still required to select the most organizational structure specific to their circumstances.