Which is the leading cause of spinal cord injury since 2015?
Introduction Show Spinal cord injury (SCI) is a kind of high disabling injury; it not only can lead to damage or loss of sensation and motor function, but also may lead to multiple organ dysfunction. Although some treatment methods such as cell therapy have played a beneficial clinical effect, there is no effective measure to cure SCI.1 Its expensive treatment cost, long recovery treatment and the loss of labor force always bring great influence to the individual and family, and also bring a heavy burden on the society. Accordingly, a coordinated multisystem approach must be taken into consideration to treat the injury itself and the accompanying complications.2 Traumatic spinal cord injury (TSCI), one of the most devastating kinds of injury, may lead to different degrees of paralysis, loss of sensory and dysfunction of bladder or bowel. TSCI not only affect one’s health, but also generates a huge economic burden on the family and society.3 Non-traumatic spinal cord injury (NTSCI) is a special type of SCI that is not caused by traumatic reasons. The etiologies of NTSCI include vertebral spondylosis (spinal stenosis), tumorous compression, vascular ischemia and congenital disease.4–6 No matter TSCI or NTSCI, the economic burden has become an increasingly important concern for individuals and for society at large. It has been reported that the estimated SCI-associated lifetime economic burden ranged from US$1.47 million to US$3.03 million per patient in Canada, from those who suffered incomplete paraplegia to who underwent complete tetraplegia.7 The purpose of this review was to describe the epidemiological characteristics of SCI in the world in order to increase prevention awareness of individuals and society to determine the incidence of SCI and analyze the epidemiological changes with the development of economy and medical technology. Methods Search strategy We searched articles published in PubMed, Medline, EMBASE and the Web of Science between January 1993 and December 2017 using the keywords “spinal cord injury”, “traumatic spinal cord injury”, “non-traumatic spinal cord injury”, “epidemiology”. The incidence, etiology, prevalence, patient demographics, level and severity of injury, complications and mortality were reviewed from the articles. Inclusion criteria This review only included papers on human beings and that were published in English. Studies had to describe an original study involving SCI and report SCI epidemiological data. In addition, meeting abstracts, case reports and editorials were excluded from our review. Data extraction Two of the authors reviewed all the titles and abstracts independently and screened according to the inclusion criteria strictly. We explored studies that contained regional or national data on SCI epidemiology. All the references of included literatures were also screened systematically. From all the studies included, the following data were extracted: etiology, incidence, prevalence, patients’ demographics, level and severity of injury, complications and mortality of SCI. From the included articles of patients’ demographics, the following data were collected: age distribution, male:female ratio and occupations of patients. Results Etiology There are diverse causes of SCI, including falls (falls from height, simple falls), motor vehicle accidents (MVAs)/motor vehicle crashes, sports-related accidents, violence and other remaining causes of injury. Certain differences exist between regions or countries. MVAs and falls are the most common causes of injury accounting for nearly equal percentages (Table 1).8–10 The main cause of SCI in developed countries used to be MVAs, but in recent researches, it turned to be falls. However, the most common cause of SCI in nondeveloped countries was still falls.11–18
Incidence The incidence rate represents the ratio of a new disease in a particular population during a certain period of time. With the expansion of human activities, the incidence of SCI also increased gradually (Table 1). The incidence varied from 13.019 per million to 163.420 per million people. Among them, the incidence rates of developed countries ranged from 13.121 to 163.420 per million people. The rates of nondeveloped countries varied from 13.019 to 220.022 per million people. Prevalence On one hand, incidence reflects the control level of SCI and the possible requirement for improved prevention, and on the other hand, prevalence poses a challenge to health care and even personal and social resources.23 Only 3 articles represented prevalence of SCI and 2 articles reported prevalence from 49024 to 52625 per million population among developed countries. As for nondeveloped countries, only 1 article reported prevalence of about 440.026 per million people. One article represented that the total NTSCI prevalence rate was 367.2 per million in Australia.27 Patients’ demographics As demonstrated in Table 1, the numbers of males were always more than the number of females among the SCI patients. The male:female ratio ranged from 1.10:128 to 6.69:121 among developed countries. As for nondeveloped countries, the ratio varied from 1.00:126 to 7.59:1.29 The mean age of SCI in developed countries ranged from 14.630 to 67.631 years. With regard to nondeveloped countries, the average age in articles varied from 29.532 to 46.033 years. Level and severity of injury The cervical level of spine was the most common part of injury in both developed countries and nondeveloped countries (Table 2).12,19–21,34,35 Most articles reported a lower percentage of complete injury than incomplete injury, except 4 studies.16,17,32,36 In our review, when classifying the types of disabilities caused by SCI, the tetraplegia was more common than paraplegia in both developed countries and nondeveloped countries except Turkey14 and Canada.37 Motor-complete injuries (America Spinal Injury Association Impairment Scale [AIS]-A or -B) were more common for patients with traumatic SCI, while there were more motor-incomplete injuries (AIS-C or-D) for patients with NTSCI.38
Mortality In recent years, mortality of patients was still high. Estimations of SCI mortality among developed countries varied from 3.1%7 to 22.2%,39 while mortality in nondeveloped countries ranged from 1.4%18 to 20.0%19 (Table 3).
Discussion SCI not only affects patients’ physical, psychological health and social well-being, but also results in a heavy burden on families, communities and health care systems. Understanding and recognition of SCI epidemiology can help the health care system carry out further preventive measures and better allocate resources for disease management. In addition, by comparing epidemiology trends of SCI along with time in different regions, for example, the increasing trend seen in the US or the decreasing trend in Spain, all kinds of systems can collect feedback information about whether preventative measures worked or not.12,40 In our review, we have collected and integrated data, and then compared different aspects of SCI in different regions. Some regularity existed from what we got. There were significant differences in etiology, incidence, prevalence, mortality, patients’ demographics or level and severity of injury in both developed and developing countries, which may be caused by economic, science and technology, medical, geographical and even social conditions. For example, Gunshot wounds used to be the main cause of SCI in Brazil before 2003. With the development of economy and the progress of society, the main reason has become MVAs and falls.36 As for etiology of SCI, because of the growing aging population, no matter in developing or developed countries, falls gradually tend to be one of the main causes of SCI, challenging social health systems and individual economic pressure. However, MVAs are still the principal cause in some developed countries, especially after drunk and drugged driving, and even without wearing seat belts, in which major groups are young and middle-aged persons.30,41 Nearly all the sporting accidents resulting in SCI occurred in younger patients.34,42 In the increasingly stringent social security, the occurrence of violence was declining year by year.36,40 At the same time, iatrogenic SCI still cannot be ignored.43 Normative nursing and medical guidelines are of paramount significance to avoid unnecessary injury. The incidence and prevalence of SCI have increased along with the expansion of human activity. The incidence rates in developed countries ranged from 13.121 to 163.420 per million people. The rates in nondeveloped countries varied from 13.019 to 220.022 per million people. Such a broad range might be due to various sampling methods and scopes of research. Among them, NTSCI accounts for a part of proportion. Because of lack of complete reports, NTSCI has not received widespread attention.44 During an economic boom, the annual SCI incidence has increased rapidly. Only 3 articles represented prevalence of SCI and 2 articles reported prevalence from 49024 to 52625 per million population among developed countries. As for nondeveloped countries, only 1 article reported prevalence of about 440.026 per million people. In clinical epidemiological study, the evaluation of the prevalence of SCI is difficult considering that different researchers do not have a unified standard for the definition of SCI. It is of utmost significance to establish effective safety regulations for the prevention of the injury. Once the injury happens, long-term health insurance is critical for the happiness of the patients.9 As for patients’ demographics, the male:female ratio ranged from 1.10:128 to 6.69:121 among developed countries. As for nondeveloped countries, the ratio varied from 1.00:126 to 7.59:1.29 The mean age of SCI in developed countries ranged from 14.630 to 67.631 years. With regard to nondeveloped countries, the average age in articles varied from 29.532 to 46.033 years. Previous researches have shown that the age of SCI patients trends to be bimodal distribution, the first peak is 15–29 and the second is over 65 years.8 The number of male SCI patients is more than the number of female patients, considering that males are the main undertaker of family and social work. Sometimes, males’ communal activities are more frequent and often involved in dangerous activities. Laborers, farmers and the unemployed were 3 SCI groups with high risk.45 The etiology of high falls was more probably related to work, resulting in thoracic and complete injury, while the cause of low falls was more likely associated with cervical and incomplete motor dysfunction injury.46 It shows that we should pay more attention to peasants, laborers and the elderly in the prevention, hospitalization and rehabilitation of SCI. As for level and severity of SCI, cervical spinal cord was the most commonly injured site in both developed countries and nondeveloped countries.12,19–21,34,35 Complete cervical SCI always resulted in severe consequences; most of the victims died on the scene of the accident or on the way to the hospital, and so most cervical SCI patients treated in hospital were incompletely injured. Traumatic SCI mostly results in complete SCI (AIS-A or B), while incomplete injuries are more common in NTSCI patients (AIS-C or D).38 It has been reported that traumatic SCI always causes concomitant injuries, including head injuries, ribs fractures, limb or pelvic fractures and injuries of the rest of body. Extraspinal fractures are relatively common in the simultaneous occurrence of SCI.4,17 The fracture occurrence varies by etiology of injury, sex, injury level and even race. Hyponatremia, pulmonary infections, urinary tract infections, bedsores and deep venous thromboses of lower limbs are common among complications in SCI patients.45 The understanding of these associated factors will contribute to early recognition of fractures, prevention of complications, facilitate rapid mobilization and promote rehabilitation outcomes among patients with SCI.47 As for mortality, with the improvement of medical conditions, it has been stabilized, though still persists at a high level. Estimation of SCI mortality in developed countries varied from 3.1%7 to 22.2%,39 while mortality in nondeveloped countries was relatively low, ranging from 1.4%18 to 20.0%.19 Mortality is significantly related with increasing age. Mortality of SCI patients over 60 years is much higher than that of SCI patients under 60 years of age.20 As for those who reach older age will typically have incomplete or lower level SCI, and will have relatively high degrees of independence and good health.48 As reported, the mortality rate was highest within 1 year after SCI. Risk factors for death comprised heart disease, diabetes, lower levels of pulmonary function and cigarette smoking. The most common causes of death were circulatory system diseases (40%) and respiratory diseases (24%).49 Death in SCI patients is a result of the interaction of many factors, we should aim at high-risk groups, especially older and heavier patients to strengthen nurse and treatment, and actively improve the general condition of patients; at the same time, actively manage various complications, such as prevention of respiratory infection and correcting electrolyte disturbances, and so that reduce the mortality of SCI patients. Despite these comprehensive bioinformatics analyses, the current study presents several limitations. First, we found that a large proportion of studies only reported a region or city in which the SCI patients stay, and the data could not be used to infer a nationwide trend. Second, we have not listed enough articles about NTSCI due to the lack of articles referring to NTSCI. Moreover, the difference of case criteria and variable study periods has caused a certain disturbance to our analysis. Understanding and recognizing the epidemiological characteristics of SCI is indispensable for the optimal allocation of therapeutic resources and to provide more effective medical services to SCI patients. We expected, through our research, to understand the epidemiological characteristics of SCI much better in order to guide clinical practice and reduce social economic burden. Conclusion There have been a lot of changes in the trends of epidemiology of SCI. MVAs and falls are the most common causes of injury. SCI incidence varies by regions or countries. With the expansion of human activities, the incidence of SCI has gradually increased. The prevalence did not change much over time. The number of male patients was significantly more than the number of female patients. The average age of patients with SCI has a tendency to increase gradually. Cervical level of spine was the most common site of injury; patients with tetraplegia were more than those with paraplegia. Moreover, mortality has been stabilized, although still persists at a high level. Therefore, how to further reduce the incidence of SCI and improve prevention and treatment measures to promote the prognosis of SCI patients are the problems that we should study in the future. Acknowledgments This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (81501899), the State Key Program of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (81330042), the International Cooperation Program of National Natural Science Foundation of China (81620108018), the Special Program for Sino-Russian Joint Research Sponsored by the Ministry of Science and Technology, People’s Republic of China (2014DFR31210), the Key Program Sponsored by the Tianjin Science and Technology Committee, People’s Republic of China (13RCGFSY19000, 14ZCZDSY00044), the Science Foundation of Tianjin Medical University for Young Scholar (2014KYQ01) and the Science Foundation of Tianjin Medical University General Hospital for Young Scholar (ZYYFY2014037). Author contributions All authors contributed toward data analysis, drafting and revising the paper and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work. Disclosure The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work. References
What is the leading cause of spinal cord injury?The most common causes of spinal cord injuries in the United States are: Motor vehicle accidents. Auto and motorcycle accidents are the leading cause of spinal cord injuries, accounting for almost half of new spinal cord injuries each year.
Where is the most common spinal cord injury?The most common sites of injury are the cervical and thoracic areas. SCI is a common cause of permanent disability and death in children and adults.
Which 2 parts of the spine are highest risk of injury?The Areas Most Prone to Damage: Cervical and Lumbar Portions. While the spine is comprised of multiple regions, the ones most susceptible to damage are the cervical and lumbar regions.
What is the most common complication of spinal cord injury?Pressure ulcers are a common complication following SCI. Good prevention requires identifying the individuals at risk for developing pressure ulcers[49]. Pressure ulcer is the most common long term complication in SCI.
|